Protests
2016 Protests
| DECISION DATE | AGENCY NAME | PROTEST FILED BY | PROJECT TITLE | DISPOSITIVE NOTE |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12/29/2016 | National Food Authority - Region II | Region Security and Investigation Agency (RSIA) | Security Services Requirement covering the Period January 01, 2017 to December 31, 2017 | Granted | 12/15/2016 | Department of Health - Davao Regional Medical Center | Blue Sky Trading Co., Inc. | Public Bidding for the supply and delivery of Medical Equipment under IB# 16-10-016 | Granted | 11/07/2016 | Philippine Sports Commission | Multiflex RNC Philippines, Inc. | Supply and Delivery of Disposable Sleeping Mats for Batang Pinoy 2016 | Granted | 10/25/2016 | Department of Health - Office of the Secretary | Transmodal International Inc. (TMI) | Procurement of Brokerage Services under IB No. 2016-216 | Denied | 10/05/2016 | Center for Health and Development - Metro Manila | Phil PharmaWealth Inc. | Procurement of Dextrose 5% Balanced Multiple Maintenance, 1000ml (Adult) and Dextrose 5% Balanced Multiple Maintenance, 500ml (Pedia) | Granted | 09/27/2016 | Corazon Locsin Montelibano Memorial Regional Hospital | Mindanao Laboratories Services/LGC Trucking and Construction Joint Venture | (ITB-1 Standby Generator 500KVA, 3 Phase 60Hz, 230V Wye Configuration) | Denied | 09/16/2016 | Department of Health - Davao Regional Medical Center | Endure Medical, Inc., | Supply and Delivery of Drugs and Medicines IB No. 16-07-0112 | Dismissed | 09/13/2016 | Department of Budget and Management - Procurement Service | Center Point Sales & Trading, Inc. | Supply and Delivery of Paper Products, Computer Accessories and Office and Janitorial and Electrical Supplies | Denied | 08/16/2016 | Department of Health - Office of the Secretary | XIMEX Delivery Express, Inc (XDE) | Procurement of Warehousing Services under IB No. 2016-169 | Denied | 08/15/2016 | Davao Regional Medical Center (DRMC) | Endure Medical, Inc. | Invitation to Bid No. 16-07-0111 (Supply and Delivery of Drugs and Medicines) | Dismissed | 08/03/2016 | City of Tanauan, Province of Batangas | Vicarish Publication and Trading, Inc. | Supply and Delivery of Reproduction of K to 12 Learners Materials for Grade 1, and Grade 2 and Grade 7 Students. | Granted | 07/25/2016 | Quirino Memorial Medical Center | Blue Sky Trading Co. Inc. | IB No. 2016-05-16 (Low Temperature Plasma Sterilizer) | Granted | 06/27/2016 | Dr. Jose Rizal Memorial Hospital | Phil Pharmawealth, Inc. | Invitation to Bid No. PB-2016-05-11 for Procurement of Drugs and Medicines | Granted | 06/06/2016 | Power Sector Assets & Liabilities Management Corporation | Petron Corporation | Supply and Delivery of Industrial Diesel Oil for the Ilijan Natural Gas Power Plant for CY 2016 | Denied | 05/27/2016 | Camarines Norte State College | ASPEN Multi-System Corporation | Procurement for the Supply and Delivery of One (1) Unit Welding Machine (Simulator) for the College of Engineering | Granted | 05/10/2016 | Department of Health | EEA Enterprise | Procurement of Light Cured Composite Kit IB 2016-113 | Granted | 05/05/2016 | Department of Budget and Management - Procurement Service | Fil Power Group & Marketing Corporation | Public Bidding No. 16-009-2 and 16-031-2 | Denied | 04/29/2016 | Metropolitan Cebu Water District | Mindanao Laboratory Services | Procurement of Various Generator Sets under Vitens Project with a total ABC of Php 40,025,000.00 | Dismissed | 04/18/2016 | Department of Public Works and Highways - Sorsogon 1st District Engineering Office | ALXM Construction | Repair/Rehabilitation of Bacon-Sawanga-Pto Diaz Road with exception Sorsogon First Legislative District | Denied | 04/14/2016 | Department of Budget and Management - Procurement Service | SPH International Corporation | Supply and Delivery of Office Equipment and Supplies for Procurement Service under Public Bidding No. 15-074-2E (Lot No. 3: Tape, Packaging, 48mm) | Granted | 04/06/2016 | City of Valenzuela | GTC-ALDIS Philippines, Inc. | Purchase of 840 Units 43" LED TV for the Nanay Teacher Parenting Camp under PRN-023-LED-TV(ES/HS/DC)-LSB-GOODS-2016 | Denied | 04/05/2016 | Department of Health | MYKL Trading Incorporated | Procurement of Pyriproxyfen under IB No. 2016-051 | Denied | 04/04/2016 | Metropolitan Cebu Water District (MCWD) | Houston Hydrotech Products and System, Inc. | Bidding for the proposed design and construction of 1,000 cubic meter modular water tank in Oprra, Cebu City | Granted | 04/02/2016 | Department of Health | Endure Medical, Inc. | Procurement of Immunochromatographic Test Kit under IB No. 2016-038 | Denied | 03/30/2016 | Home Development Mutual Fund (Pag-Ibig Fund) Corporate Office | RJEN Innovative IT Solutions Co., Ltd. | Supply, Delivery and Implementation of Various Network Equipment Project of Pag-Ibig Fund Corporate Headquarters | Granted | 03/13/2016 | Municipality of Alfonso Lista, Province of Ifugao | PHRANARET Construction | Concreting of Caragasan to Junction Access Road, Caragasan, Alfonso Lista | Denied | 03/01/2016 | Department of Health | Blim's General Merchandise Gravel and Sand | Procurement of Sputum Cups under IB No. 2016-018 | Denied | 02/29/2016 | Veterans Memorial Medical Center (VMMC) | Philippine Pharmawealth Inc., | Procurement of Drugs and Medicines for item no. 256 "SEVOFLURANE" under Lot 01-GAA-2016 | Denied | 02/26/2016 | Department of Budget and Management - Procurement Service | Innovalite Electrical Enterprise | Supply and Delivery of Office Equipment for Procurement Service under Public Bidding No. 15-162-1E (Lot No. 1: Electric Fan, Ceiling, Orbit Type) | Granted | 02/19/2016 | Department of Budget and Management - Procurement Service | SPH International Corporation | Supply and Delivery of Writing Instruments for the Procurement Service under Public Bidding No. 15-150-2E (Lot No. 5: Sign Pen) | Denied | 02/11/2016 | Tondo Medical Center | Philippine Pharmawealth Inc., | Procurement of Drugs and Medicines under Invitation to Bid No. 2016-002 - specifically line items no. 4, 27, 57, 76, 137 and 210. | Dismissed | 02/05/2016 | Department of Public Works and Highways Regional Office No. III | EML Construction and Trading | Asset reservation of National Roads-Preventive Maintenance based on pavement management system / Highway Development and Management-4 (HDM-4), Primary Roads - Manila North Road, Bulacan 4th Leg. Dist. Province of Bulacan Network Development-Improvement/Widening of National Roads, Secondary Roads Outside N1, Olongapo-Bugallon Road, Zambales 2nd Legislative District, Province of Zambales. Network Development, Off-Carriageway Improvement including Drainage-Secondary Roads, Paniqui-Camiling-Wawa Road, Tarlac 1st Legislative District, Province of Tarlac. |
Dismissed | 02/02/2016 | Department of Transportation and Communications | E.M. Cuerpo, Inc. | Procurement of the Bicol International Airport Project Package 2A Construction of Landside Facilities (Site Development and other Buildings) | Dismissed | 02/01/2016 | Department of Public Works and Highways - Catanduanes District Engineering Office (DPWH-Catanduanes DEO) | JD Construction | Rehabilitation, Reconstruction, Upgrading of damaged paved national roads including drainage based on pavement management system / Highway Development and Management (HDM-4) JCY. Bato-Baras Road | Denied | 01/29/2016 | Veterans Memorial Medical Center (VMMC) | Philippine Pharmawealth, Inc. | Carvedilol, 6.25mg Tab Diclofenac, 50mg(as Potassium) Mefenamic Acid, 500(mg) Mupirocin, 2% Ointment, 5gml Oxytocin Synthetic, 10iu/ml, 1ml(1M, IV) |
Denied Granted Denied Denied Denied |
01/21/2016 | San Lazaro Hospital | Philippine Pharmawealth Inc., | Procurement and Delivery of Goods, Equipment, Services and Infrastructure for the Hospital for the year 2016 | Granted | 01/14/2016 | Pag-Ibig Fund Technical and Administrative Services for Southern and Southwestern Mindanao | Phiguard Security Services, Inc. | Provision of Security Services | Denied | 01/14/2016 | Jose R. Reyes Memorial Medical Center (JRRMMC) | Ultimate Care Janitorial and Allied Services | Janitorial and Pest Control Services | Granted |
2015 Protests
| DECISION DATE | AGENCY NAME | PROTEST FILED BY | PROJECT TITLE | DISPOSITIVE NOTE |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12/23/2015 | Municipality of Calamba Misamis Oriental | River Concrete Construction and Development Corporation | Construction of Core Local Roads of San Isidro Water Falls | Denied | 12/18/2015 | Department of Health | Endure Medical, Inc. | Procurement of TseKaP Package under IB No. 2015-171 | Denied | 12/01/2015 | Department of Budget and Management - Procurement Service | Oliveros Protective Equipment and Maritime Supplies | Public Bidding No. 15-124-3, or the Supply and Delivery of Inflatable Life Preserver Vest for the Philippine Navy (PN) | Granted | 11/23/2015 | Social Security System | Joint Venture of Banner Plasticard, Inc and Madras Security Printers | Outsourced Production of Unified Multi-purpose Identification (UMID) Cards for five (5) years | Denied | 11/13/2015 | Social Security System | SSS Retirees Service Corporation (SSSRSC) | Social Security System Bids and Awards Committee I Resolution Nos. 2015-140-1 for the Three (3)-Year Contract for Manpower Services | Denied | 10/23/2015 | Department of Health | Westfield Pharmaceuticals Inc. | Procurement of Metoprolol 50mg Tables under IB No. 2015-148 | Denied | 10/20/2015 | Social Security System | SSS Retirees Service Corporation (SSSRSC) | Social Security System Bids and Awards Committee I Resolution Nos. 2015-127-9 for the Three (3)-Year Contract for Manpower Services | Denied | 10/15/2015 | Land Transportation Office Region I (LTO-RO I) | Baguio`s Finest Security Agency | Procurement of Security Services covering the period of January 01, 2016 to December 31, 2016 | Granted | 10/14/2015 | Department of Health | Globo Asiatico Enterprises, Inc. | Procurement of Praziquantel under ITB No. 2015-92 | Denied | 10/08/2015 | Social Security System | Joint Venture AllCard Plastics Philippines, Inc. and Stradcom Corporation | Procurement of Outsourced Production of Unified Multi-Purpose Identification (UMID) Cards | Granted | 09/17/2015 | Department of Public Works and Highways - Agusan del Norte District Engineering Office | Joan Construction | Construction of 2 STY 4-CL Del Pilar NHS (Calamba NHS Annex) | Dismissed | 09/16/2015 | Maritime Industry Authority | Commerce Asia, Inc. | Procurement of ID Card printer and ID Cards and Consumables for Marina Licenses under Memorandum Circular No. 2012-03 | Denied | 09/02/2015 | Veterans Memorial Medical Center | Lunarmed Pharma Trading | Procurement of Drugs and Medicines for Calendar Year 2015 | Granted | 08/28/2015 | Bureau of Fire Protection - Regional Office I | D Multi Essense Products | Procurement of Steel Cabinets for the use of BFP Region I with reference no. 2015-07-20 | Denied | 08/03/2015 | Department of Health - Regional Office I | Endure Medical, Inc. | Procurement and Delivery of BUB and HFEP Equipment | Denied | 07/20/2015 | Department of Budget and Management - Procurement Service | L.M.S. Industries | Supply and Delivery of Air Freshener, Mono Block Chair and Masking Tape for PS Stocks under Public Bidding No. 15-059-1E | Denied | 07/15/2015 | Department of Environment and Natural Resources - Region V | MCRG Engineering Services and Technical Consultancy | DENR-5-TS-RFPS-01-2015; DENR-5-V-TS-FS-01-2015; DENR-5-V-TS-FS-02-2015 | Granted | 07/10/2015 | Department of Transportation and Communication | Joint Venture of Omniprime Marketing Inc., and Heitech Padu Berhad | Bidding for the DOTC Road Transportation IT Infrastructure Project - LTO Component | Denied | 07/06/2015 | Province of Misamis Oriental | TKC Heavy Industries Corporation | Supply and Delivery of Brand New Road Construction and Maintenance Equipment of the Province of Misamis Oriental | Denied | 06/25/2015 | Department of Budget and Management - Procurement Service (DBM-PS) | SPH International Corporation | Supply and Delivery of Janitorial Supplies, Carbon Film, Notebook-Stenographer and Pencil for PS Stocks under PB No. 15-033-1E (Lot No. 4: Mop Bucket) | Granted | 06/22/2015 | Department of Transportation and Communications - Metro Rail Transit 3 (DOTC-MRT3) | Global Epcom Services, Inc. | Short-Term Maintenance Service Provider of the Rolling Stocks, Depot Equipment and Signaling System for Six (6) Months with an ABC of One Hundred Forty Nine Million Pesos (PHP149,000,000.00) | Denied | 06/04/2015 | Department of Science and Technology Regional Office No. VI | Prince Valiant International Corp. | Procurement of various laboratory and Office Equipment | Dismissed | 06/01/2015 | PITC - Pharma Inc. | Endure Medical Inc. | Procurement of Ice-Lined Vaccine Refrigirator for DOH with project reference no. BAC/GOODS/2015-002 | Denied | 05/18/2015 | Bureau of Customs (BOC) | Joint Venture of OmniPrime Marketing Inc., Bluebell Corporation of the Philippines and Perl Tech Consulting International Inc., | Supply, Delivery, Installation, Configuration, Testing and Commissioning of E2M RDBMS with Audit and Database Appliance | Denied | 05/14/2015 | Calumpit Water District | JEMA Multi-Trading Inc. | Supply and Delivery of various materials to be used for the installation of waterline at Phase II, Northville 14, Iba O este, Calumpit Bulacan | Denied | 04/29/2015 | Tondo Medical Center | Phil Pharmawealth, Inc. | Several Line Items of Drugs and Medicines offered under Invitation to Bid No. 2014-12-04-15 | Dismissed | 04/24/2015 | Valenzuela Medical Center | Endure Medical Inc. | Procurement of Drugs and Medicines and Some Medical Supplies (CY 2015) offered under Invitation to Bid (Public Bidding) No. VMC-2014-031 | Denied | 04/17/2015 | Bureau of Internal Revenue | AMA Construction | Construction of a stockroom in BIR-Surigao City | Denied | 03/30/2015 | Veterans Memorial Medical Center (VMMC) | Endure Medical Inc | Procurement of various drugs and medicines for Calendar Year 2015 | Dismissed | 03/27/2015 | Department of Budget and Management - Procurement Service (DBM-PS) | Reddot Imaging Philippines | Supply, Delivery, Installation, Configuration, Testing, Commissioning, Training and Maintenance of a classroom for 1,908 Public Elementary School (Batch 27 Luzon) for the Department of Education (DepE | Partially Granted | 03/09/2015 | Government Service Insurance System | JBROS Construction Corporation | Construction of the GSIS Quezon City Branch Office Building at Elliptical Road, Diliman Quezon City | Denied | 02/25/2015 | Veterans Memorial Medical Center | ECE Pharmaceuticals, Inc. | Procurement of various drugs and medicines | Granted | 02/13/2015 | Municipality of Kalilangan, Province of Bukidnon, Office of the City Mayor | Zi 9 Builders & Supplies | Construction of Line Ditch Along Osmena Street | Granted | 02/12/2015 | Municipality of Kalilangan, Province of Bukidnon, Office of the City Mayor | A.C. Sy Construction | Construction of Line Ditch along Quezon Street; Construction of Line Ditch along Lopez-Jaena Street; Construction of Line Ditch along Fortich-Lapu Lapu Street of the Municipality of Kalilangan, Bukidn | Granted | 01/13/2015 | Province of Ifugao, Municipality of Hungduan | Paula Mae Buhong Construction | Mt. Polis-Bagtuna Farm to Market Road Improvement | Granted | 12/17/2015 | Department of Health - Central Office Bids and Awards Committee | One Top Systems Resources | Procurement of Cervical Inspection and IUD Insertion Package under IB No. 2015-172 | Denied |
2014 Protests
| DECISION DATE | AGENCY NAME | PROTEST FILED BY | PROJECT TITLE | DISPOSITIVE NOTE |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2014 | Department of Health | Variance Trading Corporation | Supply and Delivery of 400 units of Patient Monitor | Granted | 12/29/2014 | Department of Health - Regional Office IX (DOH RO IX) | Golden Buddha Investigation & Security Agency | Procurement of Security and Protective Services under Project No. 14-10-385 from the Office of the Bids and Awards Committee | Dismissed | 12/23/2014 | Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas | St. Gerrard Construction and Thaumaturgy Trade Philippines | One (1) lot re: Waterproofing of Roof Decks, Facades, and Parapets at the Security Plant Complex, Quezon City, as per BSPs Scope of Work and Specifications. ABC: Php19,085,000.0 | Denied | 12/18/2014 | Province of Davao Del Norte - Office of the Governor | MATI Investigation Security Agency Services, Inc. (MINSAS) | Procurement of Security Services for 53 Security Guards with Complete Equipage for the Security Services Requirement of the Provincial Government of Davao del Norte under Project ID/PR No. 14092061 | Denied | 12/11/2014 | Department of Health | PHILAB Industries, Inc. | Procurement of 205 units of Hematology Analyzer under ITB No. 14-012 and 184 units of Hematology Analyzer under ITB No. 14-017 | Denied | 11/26/2014 | Department of Budget and Management - Procurement Service | ACCEL Prime Technologies, Inc - Legend Tech. International Limited (APTI-LTIL) Joint Venture | Lot 18 (FlashDrive, 16GB) | Granted | 11/04/2014 | City of Valenzuela - Office of the City Mayor | Little Cady General Merchandize | Supply of Cabinets and Tables for 3S Centers under PRN-127-FUR/FIX-CEO-GOODS-2014 | Granted | 10/20/2014 | Philippine International Trading Corporation (PITC) | Defense and Protection Systems Phils., Inc. | Supply and Delivery of One (1) Lot Brand New Explosive Trace Detection System for Simultaneous Detection of Trace Amounts of Explosives and Narcotics for the Office for Transportation Security (OTS) | Granted | 10/15/2014 | Department of Budget and Management - Procurement Service | LMS Industries | Lot 19 (Detergent Powder, All Purpose) | Partly Granted | 09/22/2014 | Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas | KIM'S MANUFACTURING INDUSTRIES | Public Bidding for the One (1) lot Supply, Delivery and Installation of New Fire Detection and Alarm System for the BSP La Union Regional Office | Denied | 07/14/2014 | Cebu Port Authority | A.T. Tan Construction Corporation | a.) Repair of Solar Lighted Floating Buoys at Hagnaya Channel, Port of Hagnaya, San Regemio, Cebu and b.) Repair of Dilapidated Slabs and Beams of the Passenger Terminal Building at Port of Sta. F |
Granted | 07/14/2014 | Jose R. Reyes Memorial Medical Center (JRRMMC) | Endure Medical, Inc. | Procurement for the supplies of Propofol 10mg/ml 20ml ampule Diprofol and Sevoflurane inhalation 250 ml Sevo | Lifted | 06/25/2014 | Corazon Locsin Montelibano Memorial Regional Hospital (CLMMRH) | Infinite Care Technology Solutions, Inc. | Systems Improvement and Computerization of Medical Records | Denied | 06/19/2014 | National Maritime Polytechnic | Merit Security and Investigation Agency, Inc. | Procurement of Security Services ( Provision of Twenty Three Licensed Security Guards) | Denied | 06/16/2014 | National Kidney and Transplant Institute | Medical One Corporation | Supply and Delivery of One (1) Unit High End 2D Echo Machine with Tee Adult and Pediatric Probe with Work/Review Station | Dismissed | 05/12/2014 | Department of National Defense (DND) | Elbit Systems Land & C41 Ltd. | MITSS Acquisition Project of the Philippine Navy | Dismissed | 05/12/2014 | Tarlac City Water District | RMM Security Agency | Procurement of Security Services | Granted | 04/15/2014 | Philippine Children's Medical Center | Grepcor Diamonde Incorporated (Grepcor) | Purchase of Reagents for Hematology Tests under Reagent Tie-up Agreement | Dismissed | 03/28/2014 | National Irrigation Administration - Casecnan Multi-Purpose Irrigation and Power Project (NIA-CMIPP) | RM Pingol Construction and Development Corporation | Construction of SDC (Sta. 41+560 to Sta. 42+920) Lateral "N" and Sub-laterals including Related Structures and Supply, Delivery and Installation of Steel Gates | Dismissed | 03/27/2014 | National kidney and Transplant Institute | UNET Distributors Corporation and MEDTECS Material Technology Corporation | Outsourcing of Linen and Laundry Leasing Agreement with Manpower Services | Denied | 03/21/2014 | National Kidney and Transplant Institute | KOHL Industries Corporation | Procurement of 9,024 Bottles Alcohol 70% 1 liter | Dismissed | 03/07/2014 | National Food Authority - Region XII | Tiger Investigation Detective and Security Agency (TIDSA) | Procurement of the contract for "NFA-12 Security Services" | Dismissed | 02/06/2014 | Professional Regulatory Commission | Mega Data Corporation (MDC) | Supply and Delivery of Pre-Printed ID Card and Consumables with free use of ID Printing Equipment | Denied |
2013 Protests
| DECISION DATE | AGENCY NAME | PROTEST FILED BY | PROJECT TITLE | DISPOSITIVE NOTE |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12/04/2013 | Bureau of Customs | Facilities Protection, Inc and JVI Partner H2O Security Pty. Ltd. | Supply, Delivery, Installation, Commissioning of X-ray Inspection Machines to Various Customs Areas in Identified International Airports of Entry - Lot 3 | Denied | 11/26/2013 | Department of Health (DOH) | Super Trade Enterprise (STE) | Procurement of Power Generating Set | DIsmissed | 10/29/2013 | City of Valenzuela | Frontier Power Technologies and Allied Services | Supply and Installation of power generator sets for Project PRN-162-GEN SET-GOODS-2013 | Resolved | 09/09/2013 | AFP Retirement and Separation Benefits System | M. J. Bevant Corporation | Construction of Four (4) Alley Roads at Phase 1C, San Lorenzo South, Sta. Rosa Laguna | Denied | 09/02/2013 | Jose R. Reyes Memorial Medical Center | RB Alcazar Construction and Development | Repair/Renovation of Ob-Gyne, NICU, including Hallways and repair and renovation of EENT Ward (Conversion to PhilHealth Room) | Dismissed | 08/22/2013 | National Irrigation Administration | Opell Construction and Development | Construction of Bago RIS Canal Structures and Terminal Facilities with Contract Reference No. NIAR6-RREIS13-BAGO-CW38-13 | Dismissed | 07/04/2013 | Department of Education - Region III Central Luzon, Division of Nueva Ecija | Far East Eagle Construction and Development (FEECAD) | Project R3-D6-24-02, Sto. Rosario National High School; Project R3-D6-24-01, Jaen National High School and Project R3-D6-24-03, Talavera National High School | Dismissed | 05/15/2013 | Philippine Coast Guard (PCG) | Fabmik Construction and Equipment Co., Inc. | Procurement of Fifteen (15) Units of M35 Truck | Denied | 02/20/2013 | Office of the President of the Philippines | Lockheed Detective and Watchman Agency Inc. | Procurement of Private Security Services of the Office of the President CY 2013 | Dismissed |
2012 Protests
| DECISION DATE | AGENCY NAME | PROTEST FILED BY | PROJECT TITLE | DISPOSITIVE NOTE |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12/27/2012 | Department of Education (DepEd) Regional Office VIII | Villa Veronica Construction (VVC) | Repair and repainting of various Buildings in Regional Office VIII | Denied | 12/20/2012 | House of Representatives | Lockheed Detective and Watchman Agency Inc. | Annual Procurement of Private Security Agency Services for CY2013 | Granted | 11/26/2012 | Armed Forces of the Philippines, Office of the Acting Commanding General | 911 Alarm, Inc. | Procurement of Water Rescue Equipment | Denied | 11/26/2012 | Armed Forces of the Philippines | 911 Alarm, Inc. | PB-PAFBAC-112-12, Procurement of Water Rescue Equipment | Denied | 11/23/2012 | University of the Philippines - Mindanao | Mati Investigation Security Agency Services, Inc. | Supply of Security Services | Denied | 11/20/2012 | Province of Iloilo - Office of the Governor | Diomar Trading | BID NO. DVP-12-0182-B | Granted | 10/31/2012 | Department of Health (DOH) | Macare Medical, Inc. | Protest on the COBAC decision dated October 31, 2012 in the matter of the procurement of blood bank and laboratory equipment under IB NO. 2012-126 | Denied | 10/18/2012 | Municipality of Leon, Province of Iloilo | Tacolod Enterprises, Inc | Construction of Multi-purpose Public Market Building | Granted | 08/15/2012 | Land Bank of the Philippines | Banner Plasticard, Inc. | Supply and Delivery of 555,000 pcs. ATM Plastic Card (Cash Card) | Denied | 08/13/2012 | Department of Health - Center for HealthDevelopment, Central Visayas | ANA Construction | Upgrading of PNP Hospital (Phase II) at Gorodo Avenue, Cebu City | Denied | 07/25/2012 | Department of Education Region V | CPR Construction and Supply | Cluster 13-Construction of School Buildings (BEFF CY 2011) | Dismissed | 07/17/2012 | Department of Public Works and Highways - Cordillera Administrative Region, Baguio City | MARCONS BUILDER | Completion/Continuation of fence at Burnham Park, Baguio City, Project I.D. 12PD0029 | Denied | 07/12/2012 | Division of City Schools - Tabaco City | Jag-Vail Construction & Supply | Two Classroom 7m x 9m(PAGCOR Project CY 2012) | Granted | 06/25/2012 | National Food Authority - National Office I, San Juan La Union | Jodaar Cottage Industries | Bidding for the Procurement of Rice Empty Sack (MTS) | Dismissed | 06/22/2012 | National Food Authority | Tiger Investigation Detective Security Agency and General Services | Bidding for the NFA-Region IX Security Services | Granted | 06/22/2012 | Asingan Water District | VINHAR Construction & Marketing | Expansion of Water Supply System in the Northern Barangays of the Municipality of Asingan. | Denied | 06/13/2012 | Asingan Water District | TGV Builders, Inc. | Expansion of Water Supply System in the Northern Barangays of the Municipality of Asingan. | Denied | 06/11/2012 | Philippine Health Insurance Corporation | Mati Investigation Security Agency Services, Inc. | Procurement of Security Services | Dismissed | 06/07/2012 | Department of Health | MAX Copy Center | Reproduction of CHT forms for NHTS Families, CHT logbook (loose forms) and CHT reporting forms | Denied | 05/25/2012 | Lung Center of the Philippines | Zenith Medical Equipment, Inc. | Procurement of Laparoscopic Equipment System | Denied | 04/18/2012 | Philippine Health Insurance Corporation | Banner Plasticard, Inc. | Procurement of 5,300,000 pieces of Enhanced PhilHealth Identification Cards for the National Household Targeting System for Poverty Reduction (NHTS-PR) | Denied | 04/10/2012 | Department of Health | Sel-J Pharmaceuticals and Distributors | Procurement of various Drugs and Medicines for the DOH complete treatment pack for the conditional cash transfer areas under IB no. 2012-02-06(04) | Dismissed | 03/30/2012 | Intramuros Administration | Ultimate Care Janitorial and Allied Services | Bidding for Janitorial Services for Fiscal Year 2012 | Denied | 03/06/2012 | DOH - Center for Health Development - Eastern Visayas | Joint Venture of AP & Printshoppe & Publishing and Malones Printing Press & Publishing House | Public Bidding for the Construction of the Zumarraga level Hospital | Dismissed | 02/28/2012 | Province of Aklan, Office of the Provincial Governor | Diomar Trading | Procurement of Medical Supplies for Ibajay District Hospital (Solicitation/ITB No. Aklan-2013-010) | Denied | 02/14/2012 | Government Service Insurance System | Malayan Insurance Company, Inc. | City Government of Makati & Subic Bay Metropolitan Authority-International Container Terminal Services, Inc. Reinsurance Procurement | Denied | 02/14/2012 | Government Service Insurance System | Malayan Insurance Company, Inc. | City Government of Makati & Subic Bay Metropolitan Authority-International Container Terminal Services, Inc. Reinsurance Procurement | Denied | 01/18/2012 | Clark Development Corporation | Kart Plaza Manufacturing, Inc. | Supply and Delivery of Thirty (30) Units Brand New 2-Seater Electric Golf Carts for CDC-SPRO | Denied | 01/05/2012 | North Luzon Railways Corporation | ABE General Contractor | Repair and Renovation of NORTHRAIL Office | Denied |
2011 Protests
| DECISION DATE | AGENCY NAME | PROTEST FILED BY | PROJECT TITLE | DISPOSITIVE NOTE |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12/23/2011 | Home Development Mutual Fund | Logic Solutions Inc. | Supply, Delivery and Installation of HDMF IP Telephony/PABX System | Denied | 12/22/2011 | Municipality of Kalilangan, Province of Bukidnon | OC Pizarro Construction and Supplies | Construction of new Municipal Sangguniang Bayan Building of the Municipality of Kalilangan | Denied | 12/08/2011 | Bureau of Fire Protection Regional Headquarters - Calabarzon | Den Tronix International Trading | BFP R4A, Fire Hoses 1 1/2 “ X 50’ and 2 ½” x 50’ | Denied | 12/06/2011 | Municipal Government of Baggao, Cagayan | Mariver Trading and General Merchanise | Supply and Delivery of Biological Mosquito Larvicides | Denied | 09/29/2011 | Department of Health - Corazon Locsin Montelibano Memorial Regional Hospital | MedicoTek, Inc. | Drop Light (LED) Operating Light | Granted | 09/05/2011 | Department of Social Welfare and Development - Region 10 | Studio Graphics Corpoartion | Printing and Delivery of "Pantawid Pamilya Guide Booklet" | Denied | 08/11/2011 | DTM Prints and Labels, Inc. | Power Plates Development Concepts | Procurement of the Iloilo City Business Tax Plates | Denied | 08/04/2011 | Zamboanga City Water District | Keylargo Industrial Sales, Inc. | Supply of 8,200 units of water meters | Denied | 08/03/2011 | Zamboanga City Water District | Zebra Construction & Development Corporation | Concreting of Road and Construction of Lined Canal at Sola Street, Barangay III, Kabankalan City, Negros Occidental | Denied | 07/22/2011 | Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas | Ameresco Commercial and Industrial Co., Inc. | Replacement of eleven (11) units PVC fill of "Marley" Cooling Tower | Denied | 06/03/2011 | Department of Public Works and Highways - 2nd DEO | B.C. Cuerpo Construction Corporation | Rehabilitation/Improvement of Road at Patiis-Abuab Road at Brgy. Malanday Guitnang Bayan II, San Mateo Rizal | Denied | 04/26/2011 | DepEd-Division of Taguig City and Pateros | Trojan Marketing, Inc. | Procurement of school furniture | Denied | 03/10/2011 | National Commission for Culture and the Arts | J.D. Legaspi Construction | NA | Denied for filing out of time | 03/07/2011 | National Irrigation Administration | Brostan Construction and Development | Construction of Bulao Diversion Dam, Irrigation and Drainage Canals and Appurtenant Facilities/ Structures Including Supply, Delivery and Installation of Steel Gates for HCAAP. | Granted | 02/17/2011 | Department of Public Works and Highways - Office of the District Engineer - Zamboanga City | Unitec Builders, Inc. | Repair/Rehabilitation of Barangay Road, Bunguiao, Zamboanga City | Denied | 01/17/2011 | Department of Public Works and Highways | J.D. Legaspi Construction | Improvement of Sito Libis-Bulihan Centro Roxas-Duluhan Road, Bulihan Arc, San Antonio, Quezon Province | Denied Motion for Reconsideration | 01/12/2011 | Land Transportation Office - Regional Office 2 | Region Security and Investigation Agency | Delivery of Security Services | Denied due to lack of basis | 01/03/2011 | Corazon Locsin Montelibano Memorial Regional Hospital | Phi Pharmawealth Incorporated | Sevoflurane for Drugs and Medi | Granted Protest | 01/03/2011 | Environmental Management Bureau - Department of Environment and Natural Resources | BP Integrated Technologies, Inc. | NA | Denied Motion for Reconsideration |
2010 Protests
| DECISION DATE | AGENCY NAME | PROTEST FILED BY | PROJECT TITLE | DISPOSITIVE NOTE |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12/28/2010 | National Bureau of Investigation | System & Plan Integrator & Development Corporation | NBI Citizen's Database and Information System Project | Denied Motion for Reconsideration | 12/22/2010 | St. Anthony Mother and Child Hospital | San Narciso Builders Corporation | Construction of a 3 storey Annex Building, Completion of the 3rd floor of Dr. Manuel Cuenco Building and Ramp | Denied for non-compliance | 12/17/2010 | Philippine Reclamation Authority | J.D. Legaspi Corporation | Construction of the Service Road at Superblock A | Denied for lack of merit | 12/16/2010 | National Youth Commission | Care Best International, Inc. | Procurement of Janitorial Services | Denied Motion for Reconsideration | 12/10/2010 | Veterans Memorial Medical Center | Jagas Dental Trading | Procurement of four (4) units Dental Chair | Denied for lack of merit | 09/27/2010 | Zamboanga City Water District | Keylargo Industrial Sales | Supply and delivery of 3,000 Units of Water Meters 1/2 Class C Positive Displacement Type, Volumetric, Plastic Casing | Denied for lack of merit | 09/09/2010 | Province of Daval del Norte | Davao Rock Mixer Enterprises | Improvement of Balet-Danao-Kila Road | Dismissed for lack of merit | 08/20/2010 | Philippine Nuclear Research Institute | Simplified Builders | Construction of two (2) storey building extension of Cobalt 60 irradiation facility building (Phase 2) and upgrading of the existing radioactive waste facility | Denied for non-compliance | 08/05/2010 | Social Security System | Greenmar Phils. | Supply, delivery and installation of tellering booth, bill/money counter and cash safe/vault for various SSS Branch Offices. | Denied for non-compliance in the submission of the | 06/07/2010 | Veterans Memorial Medical Center | Ultimate Care Janitorial Services | Janitorial Services | Denied for violation of the contract agreement | 05/21/2010 | North Luzon Railways Corporation | Superb Security & Investigation Agency, Inc. | Security Services | Dismissed for lack of merit | 04/12/2010 | Philippine International Trading Corporation | Super Trade Enterprises | Supply and Delivery of Brand New Mototr Vehicles and Motorcycles for the PDEA | Dismissed for lack of merit | 03/18/2010 | Southern Philippines Medical Center | Mati Investigation and Allied Services, Inc. | Security Services | Denied being filed out of time | 02/18/2010 | DepEd NCR | LGR Athletic Wears, Inc. | Supply and Delivery of Sports Athletic Uniforms for the Palarong Pambansaa CY 2010 | Denied for filing out of time | 01/29/2010 | Davao Medical Center | Redmark Industrial and Medical Supplies | Lease of Chemistry and Immunology equipments and its reagents and laboratory supplies | Denied for failure to meet or comply with the tech | 01/22/2010 | Municipality of Sinait, Province of Ilocos Sur | Magscon Construction | Various Infrastructure projects | Denied for repeating the same issues that was alre |
2009 Protests
| DECISION DATE | AGENCY NAME | PROTEST FILED BY | PROJECT TITLE | DISPOSITIVE NOTE |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12/11/2009 | Philippine Science High School | San Narciso Builders | Construction of Academic HUB | Granted. Decision of the bids and awards committee | 12/03/2009 | DOH-Amang Rodriguez Memorial Medical Center | Ritegroup Marketing, Inc | Procurement of Blood Bags | Denied for lack of merit | 08/07/2009 | National Printing Office | Ready Form Inc. | Printing of Government Accountable Forms | Appeal from the decision of NPO is Denied | 04/20/2009 | Department of Health | Phil. Pharmawealth, Inc. | Procurement of Anti-TB Drugs for Children | Denied for failure to meet or comply with the elig | 02/12/2009 | Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas | Safeco Environmental Services, Inc. | Removal of the Structural Fireproofing Materials on Steel Beams of the Multi-storey Building | Reconsidered under the minimum eligibility require |