Protest

  • 2014
  • 2013
  • 2012
  • 2011
  • 2010
  • 2009

04/15/2014

Agency: Philippine Children's Medical Center

Protesting Entity: Grepcor Diamonde Incorporated (Grepcor)

Project: Purchase of Reagents for Hematology Tests under Reagent Tie-up Agreement

Dispositive Note: Dismissed

03/28/2014

Agency: National Irrigation Administration - Casecnan Multi-Purpose Irrigation and Power Project (NIA-CMIPP)

Protesting Entity: RM Pingol Construction and Development Corporation

Project: Construction of SDC (Sta. 41+560 to Sta. 42+920) Lateral "N" and Sub-laterals including Related Structures and Supply, Delivery and Installation of Steel Gates

Dispositive Note: Dismissed

03/07/2014

Agency: National Food Authority - Region XII

Protesting Entity: Tiger Investigation Detective and Security Agency (TIDSA)

Project: Procurement of the contract for "NFA-12 Security Services"

Dispositive Note: Dismissed

02/06/2014

Agency: Professional Regulatory Commission

Protesting Entity: Mega Data Corporation (MDC)

Project: Supply and Delivery of Pre-Printed ID Card and Consumables with free use of ID Printing Equipment

Dispositive Note: Denied

12/04/2013

Agency: Bureau of Customs

Protesting Entity: Facilities Protection, Inc and JVI Partner H2O Security Pty. Ltd.

Project: Supply, Delivery, Installation, Commissioning of X-ray Inspection Machines to Various Customs Areas in Identified International Airports of Entry - Lot 3

Dispositive Note: Denied

11/26/2013

Agency: Department of Health (DOH)

Protesting Entity: Super Trade Enterprise (STE)

Project: Procurement of Power Generating Set

Dispositive Note: DIsmissed

10/29/2013

Agency: City of Valenzuela

Protesting Entity: Frontier Power Technologies and Allied Services

Project: Supply and Installation of power generator sets for Project PRN-162-GEN SET-GOODS-2013

Dispositive Note: Resolved

09/09/2013

Agency: AFP Retirement and Separation Benefits System

Protesting Entity: M. J. Bevant Corporation

Project: Construction of Four (4) Alley Roads at Phase 1C, San Lorenzo South, Sta. Rosa Laguna

Dispositive Note: Denied

09/02/2013

Agency: Jose R. Reyes Memorial Medical Center

Protesting Entity: RB Alcazar Construction and Development

Project: Repair/Renovation of Ob-Gyne, NICU, including Hallways and repair and renovation of EENT Ward (Conversion to PhilHealth Room)

Dispositive Note: Dismissed

08/22/2013

Agency: National Irrigation Administration

Protesting Entity: Opell Construction and Development

Project: Construction of Bago RIS Canal Structures and Terminal Facilities with Contract Reference No. NIAR6-RREIS13-BAGO-CW38-13

Dispositive Note: Dismissed

07/04/2013

Agency: Department of Education - Region III Central Luzon, Division of Nueva Ecija

Protesting Entity: Far East Eagle Construction and Development (FEECAD)

Project: Project R3-D6-24-02, Sto. Rosario National High School; Project R3-D6-24-01, Jaen National High School and Project R3-D6-24-03, Talavera National High School

Dispositive Note: Dismissed

05/15/2013

Agency: Philippine Coast Guard (PCG)

Protesting Entity: Fabmik Construction and Equipment Co., Inc.

Project: Procurement of Fifteen (15) Units of M35 Truck

Dispositive Note: Denied

02/20/2013

Agency: Office of the President of the Philippines

Protesting Entity: Lockheed Detective and Watchman Agency Inc.

Project: Procurement of Private Security Services of the Office of the President CY 2013

Dispositive Note: Dismissed

12/27/2012

Agency: Department of Education (DepEd) Regional Office VIII

Protesting Entity: Villa Veronica Construction (VVC)

Project: Repair and repainting of various Buildings in Regional Office VIII

Dispositive Note: Denied

12/20/2012

Agency: House of Representatives

Protesting Entity: Lockheed Detective and Watchman Agency Inc.

Project: Annual Procurement of Private Security Agency Services for CY2013

Dispositive Note: Granted

11/26/2012

Agency: Armed Forces of the Philippines, Office of the Acting Commanding General

Protesting Entity: 911 Alarm, Inc.

Project: Procurement of Water Rescue Equipment

Dispositive Note: Denied

11/26/2012

Agency: Armed Forces of the Philippines

Protesting Entity: 911 Alarm, Inc.

Project: PB-PAFBAC-112-12, Procurement of Water Rescue Equipment

Dispositive Note: Denied

11/23/2012

Agency: University of the Philippines - Mindanao

Protesting Entity: Mati Investigation Security Agency Services, Inc.

Project: Supply of Security Services

Dispositive Note: Denied

11/20/2012

Agency: Province of Iloilo - Office of the Governor

Protesting Entity: Diomar Trading

Project: BID NO. DVP-12-0182-B

Dispositive Note: Granted

10/31/2012

Agency: Department of Health (DOH)

Protesting Entity: Macare Medical, Inc.

Project: Protest on the COBAC decision dated October 31, 2012 in the matter of the procurement of blood bank and laboratory equipment under IB NO. 2012-126

Dispositive Note: Denied

10/18/2012

Agency: Municipality of Leon, Province of Iloilo

Protesting Entity: Tacolod Enterprises, Inc

Project: Construction of Multi-purpose Public Market Building

Dispositive Note: Granted

08/15/2012

Agency: Land Bank of the Philippines

Protesting Entity: Banner Plasticard, Inc.

Project: Supply and Delivery of 555,000 pcs. ATM Plastic Card (Cash Card)

Dispositive Note: Denied

08/13/2012

Agency: Department of Health - Center for HealthDevelopment, Central Visayas

Protesting Entity: ANA Construction

Project: Upgrading of PNP Hospital (Phase II) at Gorodo Avenue, Cebu City

Dispositive Note: Denied

07/25/2012

Agency: Department of Education Region V

Protesting Entity: CPR Construction and Supply

Project: Cluster 13-Construction of School Buildings (BEFF CY 2011)

Dispositive Note: Dismissed

07/17/2012

Agency: Department of Public Works and Highways - Cordillera Administrative Region, Baguio City

Protesting Entity: MARCONS BUILDER

Project: Completion/Continuation of fence at Burnham Park, Baguio City, Project I.D. 12PD0029

Dispositive Note: Denied

07/12/2012

Agency: Division of City Schools - Tabaco City

Protesting Entity: Jag-Vail Construction & Supply

Project: Two Classroom 7m x 9m(PAGCOR Project CY 2012)

Dispositive Note: Granted

06/25/2012

Agency: National Food Authority - National Office I, San Juan La Union

Protesting Entity: Jodaar Cottage Industries

Project: Bidding for the Procurement of Rice Empty Sack (MTS)

Dispositive Note: Dismissed

06/22/2012

Agency: National Food Authority

Protesting Entity: Tiger Investigation Detective Security Agency and General Services

Project: Bidding for the NFA-Region IX Security Services

Dispositive Note: Granted

06/22/2012

Agency: Asingan Water District

Protesting Entity: VINHAR Construction & Marketing

Project: Expansion of Water Supply System in the Northern Barangays of the Municipality of Asingan.

Dispositive Note: Denied

06/13/2012

Agency: Asingan Water District

Protesting Entity: TGV Builders, Inc.

Project: Expansion of Water Supply System in the Northern Barangays of the Municipality of Asingan.

Dispositive Note: Denied

06/11/2012

Agency: Philippine Health Insurance Corporation

Protesting Entity: Mati Investigation Security Agency Services, Inc.

Project: Procurement of Security Services

Dispositive Note: Dismissed

06/07/2012

Agency: Department of Health

Protesting Entity: MAX Copy Center

Project: Reproduction of CHT forms for NHTS Families, CHT logbook (loose forms) and CHT reporting forms

Dispositive Note: Denied

05/25/2012

Agency: Lung Center of the Philippines

Protesting Entity: Zenith Medical Equipment, Inc.

Project: Procurement of Laparoscopic Equipment System

Dispositive Note: Denied

04/18/2012

Agency: Philippine Health Insurance Corporation

Protesting Entity: Banner Plasticard, Inc.

Project: Procurement of 5,300,000 pieces of Enhanced PhilHealth Identification Cards for the National Household Targeting System for Poverty Reduction (NHTS-PR)

Dispositive Note: Denied

04/10/2012

Agency: Department of Health

Protesting Entity: Sel-J Pharmaceuticals and Distributors

Project: Procurement of various Drugs and Medicines for the DOH complete treatment pack for the conditional cash transfer areas under IB no. 2012-02-06(04)

Dispositive Note: Dismissed

03/30/2012

Agency: Intramuros Administration

Protesting Entity: Ultimate Care Janitorial and Allied Services

Project: Bidding for Janitorial Services for Fiscal Year 2012

Dispositive Note: Denied

03/06/2012

Agency: DOH - Center for Health Development - Eastern Visayas

Protesting Entity: Joint Venture of AP & Printshoppe & Publishing and Malones Printing Press & Publishing House

Project: Public Bidding for the Construction of the Zumarraga level Hospital

Dispositive Note: Dismissed

02/28/2012

Agency: Province of Aklan, Office of the Provincial Governor

Protesting Entity: Diomar Trading

Project: Procurement of Medical Supplies for Ibajay District Hospital (Solicitation/ITB No. Aklan-2013-010)

Dispositive Note: Denied

02/14/2012

Agency: Government Service Insurance System

Protesting Entity: Malayan Insurance Company, Inc.

Project: City Government of Makati & Subic Bay Metropolitan Authority-International Container Terminal Services, Inc. Reinsurance Procurement

Dispositive Note: Denied

02/14/2012

Agency: Government Service Insurance System

Protesting Entity: Malayan Insurance Company, Inc.

Project: City Government of Makati & Subic Bay Metropolitan Authority-International Container Terminal Services, Inc. Reinsurance Procurement

Dispositive Note: Denied

01/18/2012

Agency: Clark Development Corporation

Protesting Entity: Kart Plaza Manufacturing, Inc.

Project: Supply and Delivery of Thirty (30) Units Brand New 2-Seater Electric Golf Carts for CDC-SPRO

Dispositive Note: Denied

01/05/2012

Agency: North Luzon Railways Corporation

Protesting Entity: ABE General Contractor

Project: Repair and Renovation of NORTHRAIL Office

Dispositive Note: Denied

12/23/2011

Agency: Home Development Mutual Fund

Protesting Entity: Logic Solutions Inc.

Project: Supply, Delivery and Installation of HDMF IP Telephony/PABX System

Dispositive Note: Denied

12/22/2011

Agency: Municipality of Kalilangan, Province of Bukidnon

Protesting Entity: OC Pizarro Construction and Supplies

Project: Construction of new Municipal Sangguniang Bayan Building of the Municipality of Kalilangan

Dispositive Note: Denied

12/08/2011

Agency: Bureau of Fire Protection Regional Headquarters - Calabarzon

Protesting Entity: Den Tronix International Trading

Project: BFP R4A, Fire Hoses 1 1/2 X 50 and 2 x 50

Dispositive Note: Denied

12/06/2011

Agency: Municipal Government of Baggao, Cagayan

Protesting Entity: Mariver Trading and General Merchanise

Project: Supply and Delivery of Biological Mosquito Larvicides

Dispositive Note: Denied

09/29/2011

Agency: Department of Health - Corazon Locsin Montelibano Memorial Regional Hospital

Protesting Entity: MedicoTek, Inc.

Project: Drop Light (LED) Operating Light

Dispositive Note: Granted

09/05/2011

Agency: Department of Social Welfare and Development - Region 10

Protesting Entity: Studio Graphics Corpoartion

Project: Printing and Delivery of "Pantawid Pamilya Guide Booklet"

Dispositive Note: Denied

08/11/2011

Agency: DTM Prints and Labels, Inc.

Protesting Entity: Power Plates Development Concepts

Project: Procurement of the Iloilo City Business Tax Plates

Dispositive Note: Denied

08/04/2011

Agency: Zamboanga City Water District

Protesting Entity: Keylargo Industrial Sales, Inc.

Project: Supply of 8,200 units of water meters

Dispositive Note: Denied

08/03/2011

Agency: Zamboanga City Water District

Protesting Entity: Zebra Construction & Development Corporation

Project: Concreting of Road and Construction of Lined Canal at Sola Street, Barangay III, Kabankalan City, Negros Occidental

Dispositive Note: Denied

07/22/2011

Agency: Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas

Protesting Entity: Ameresco Commercial and Industrial Co., Inc.

Project: Replacement of eleven (11) units PVC fill of "Marley" Cooling Tower

Dispositive Note: Denied

06/03/2011

Agency: Department of Public Works and Highways - 2nd DEO

Protesting Entity: B.C. Cuerpo Construction Corporation

Project: Rehabilitation/Improvement of Road at Patiis-Abuab Road at Brgy. Malanday Guitnang Bayan II, San Mateo Rizal

Dispositive Note: Denied

04/26/2011

Agency: DepEd-Division of Taguig City and Pateros

Protesting Entity: Trojan Marketing, Inc.

Project: Procurement of school furniture

Dispositive Note: Denied

03/10/2011

Agency: National Commission for Culture and the Arts

Protesting Entity: J.D. Legaspi Construction

Project: NA

Dispositive Note: Denied for filing out of time

03/07/2011

Agency: National Irrigation Administration

Protesting Entity: Brostan Construction and Development

Project: Construction of Bulao Diversion Dam, Irrigation and Drainage Canals and Appurtenant Facilities/ Structures Including Supply, Delivery and Installation of Steel Gates for HCAAP.

Dispositive Note: Granted

02/17/2011

Agency: Department of Public Works and Highways - Office of the District Engineer - Zamboanga City

Protesting Entity: Unitec Builders, Inc.

Project: Repair/Rehabilitation of Barangay Road, Bunguiao, Zamboanga City

Dispositive Note: Denied

01/17/2011

Agency: Department of Public Works and Highways

Protesting Entity: J.D. Legaspi Construction

Project: Improvement of Sito Libis-Bulihan Centro Roxas-Duluhan Road, Bulihan Arc, San Antonio, Quezon Province

Dispositive Note: Denied Motion for Reconsideration

01/12/2011

Agency: Land Transportation Office - Regional Office 2

Protesting Entity: Region Security and Investigation Agency

Project: Delivery of Security Services

Dispositive Note: Denied due to lack of basis

01/03/2011

Agency: Corazon Locsin Montelibano Memorial Regional Hospital

Protesting Entity: Phi Pharmawealth Incorporated

Project: Sevoflurane for Drugs and Medi

Dispositive Note: Granted Protest

01/03/2011

Agency: Environmental Management Bureau - Department of Environment and Natural Resources

Protesting Entity: BP Integrated Technologies, Inc.

Project: NA

Dispositive Note: Denied Motion for Reconsideration

12/28/2010

Agency: National Bureau of Investigation

Protesting Entity: System & Plan Integrator & Development Corporation

Project: NBI Citizen's Database and Information System Project

Dispositive Note: Denied Motion for Reconsideration

12/22/2010

Agency: St. Anthony Mother and Child Hospital

Protesting Entity: San Narciso Builders Corporation

Project: Construction of a 3 storey Annex Building, Completion of the 3rd floor of Dr. Manuel Cuenco Building and Ramp

Dispositive Note: Denied for non-compliance

12/17/2010

Agency: Philippine Reclamation Authority

Protesting Entity: J.D. Legaspi Corporation

Project: Construction of the Service Road at Superblock A

Dispositive Note: Denied for lack of merit

12/16/2010

Agency: National Youth Commission

Protesting Entity: Care Best International, Inc.

Project: Procurement of Janitorial Services

Dispositive Note: Denied Motion for Reconsideration

12/10/2010

Agency: Veterans Memorial Medical Center

Protesting Entity: Jagas Dental Trading

Project: Procurement of four (4) units Dental Chair

Dispositive Note: Denied for lack of merit

09/27/2010

Agency: Zamboanga City Water District

Protesting Entity: Keylargo Industrial Sales

Project: Supply and delivery of 3,000 Units of Water Meters 1/2 Class C Positive Displacement Type, Volumetric, Plastic Casing

Dispositive Note: Denied for lack of merit

09/09/2010

Agency: Province of Daval del Norte

Protesting Entity: Davao Rock Mixer Enterprises

Project: Improvement of Balet-Danao-Kila Road

Dispositive Note: Dismissed for lack of merit

08/20/2010

Agency: Philippine Nuclear Research Institute

Protesting Entity: Simplified Builders

Project: Construction of two (2) storey building extension of Cobalt 60 irradiation facility building (Phase 2) and upgrading of the existing radioactive waste facility

Dispositive Note: Denied for non-compliance

08/05/2010

Agency: Social Security System

Protesting Entity: Greenmar Phils.

Project: Supply, delivery and installation of tellering booth, bill/money counter and cash safe/vault for various SSS Branch Offices.

Dispositive Note: Denied for non-compliance in the submission of the

06/07/2010

Agency: Veterans Memorial Medical Center

Protesting Entity: Ultimate Care Janitorial Services

Project: Janitorial Services

Dispositive Note: Denied for violation of the contract agreement

05/21/2010

Agency: North Luzon Railways Corporation

Protesting Entity: Superb Security & Investigation Agency, Inc.

Project: Security Services

Dispositive Note: Dismissed for lack of merit

04/12/2010

Agency: Philippine International Trading Corporation

Protesting Entity: Super Trade Enterprises

Project: Supply and Delivery of Brand New Mototr Vehicles and Motorcycles for the PDEA

Dispositive Note: Dismissed for lack of merit

03/18/2010

Agency: Southern Philippines Medical Center

Protesting Entity: Mati Investigation and Allied Services, Inc.

Project: Security Services

Dispositive Note: Denied being filed out of time

02/18/2010

Agency: DepEd NCR

Protesting Entity: LGR Athletic Wears, Inc.

Project: Supply and Delivery of Sports Athletic Uniforms for the Palarong Pambansaa CY 2010

Dispositive Note: Denied for filing out of time

01/29/2010

Agency: Davao Medical Center

Protesting Entity: Redmark Industrial and Medical Supplies

Project: Lease of Chemistry and Immunology equipments and its reagents and laboratory supplies

Dispositive Note: Denied for failure to meet or comply with the tech

01/22/2010

Agency: Municipality of Sinait, Province of Ilocos Sur

Protesting Entity: Magscon Construction

Project: Various Infrastructure projects

Dispositive Note: Denied for repeating the same issues that was alre

12/11/2009

Agency: Philippine Science High School

Protesting Entity: San Narciso Builders

Project: Construction of Academic HUB

Dispositive Note: Granted. Decision of the bids and awards committee

12/03/2009

Agency: DOH-Amang Rodriguez Memorial Medical Center

Protesting Entity: Ritegroup Marketing, Inc

Project: Procurement of Blood Bags

Dispositive Note: Denied for lack of merit

08/07/2009

Agency: National Printing Office

Protesting Entity: Ready Form Inc.

Project: Printing of Government Accountable Forms

Dispositive Note: Appeal from the decision of NPO is Denied

04/20/2009

Agency: Department of Health

Protesting Entity: Phil. Pharmawealth, Inc.

Project: Procurement of Anti-TB Drugs for Children

Dispositive Note: Denied for failure to meet or comply with the elig

02/12/2009

Agency: Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas

Protesting Entity: Safeco Environmental Services, Inc.

Project: Removal of the Structural Fireproofing Materials on Steel Beams of the Multi-storey Building

Dispositive Note: Reconsidered under the minimum eligibility require