Protest

  • 2014
  • 2013
  • 2012
  • 2011
  • 2010
  • 2009

07/14/2014

Agency: Cebu Port Authority

Protesting Entity: A.T. Tan Construction Corporation

Project: a.) Repair of Solar Lighted Floating Buoys at Hagnaya Channel, Port of Hagnaya, San Regemio, Cebu and
b.) Repair of Dilapidated Slabs and Beams of the Passenger Terminal Building at Port of Sta. F

Dispositive Note: Granted

06/25/2014

Agency: Corazon Locsin Montelibano Memorial Regional Hospital (CLMMRH)

Protesting Entity: Infinite Care Technology Solutions, Inc.

Project: Systems Improvement and Computerization of Medical Records

Dispositive Note: Denied

05/12/2014

Agency: Tarlac City Water District

Protesting Entity: RMM Security Agency

Project: Procurement of Security Services

Dispositive Note: Granted

04/15/2014

Agency: Philippine Children's Medical Center

Protesting Entity: Grepcor Diamonde Incorporated (Grepcor)

Project: Purchase of Reagents for Hematology Tests under Reagent Tie-up Agreement

Dispositive Note: Dismissed

03/28/2014

Agency: National Irrigation Administration - Casecnan Multi-Purpose Irrigation and Power Project (NIA-CMIPP)

Protesting Entity: RM Pingol Construction and Development Corporation

Project: Construction of SDC (Sta. 41+560 to Sta. 42+920) Lateral "N" and Sub-laterals including Related Structures and Supply, Delivery and Installation of Steel Gates

Dispositive Note: Dismissed

03/07/2014

Agency: National Food Authority - Region XII

Protesting Entity: Tiger Investigation Detective and Security Agency (TIDSA)

Project: Procurement of the contract for "NFA-12 Security Services"

Dispositive Note: Dismissed

02/06/2014

Agency: Professional Regulatory Commission

Protesting Entity: Mega Data Corporation (MDC)

Project: Supply and Delivery of Pre-Printed ID Card and Consumables with free use of ID Printing Equipment

Dispositive Note: Denied

12/04/2013

Agency: Bureau of Customs

Protesting Entity: Facilities Protection, Inc and JVI Partner H2O Security Pty. Ltd.

Project: Supply, Delivery, Installation, Commissioning of X-ray Inspection Machines to Various Customs Areas in Identified International Airports of Entry - Lot 3

Dispositive Note: Denied

11/26/2013

Agency: Department of Health (DOH)

Protesting Entity: Super Trade Enterprise (STE)

Project: Procurement of Power Generating Set

Dispositive Note: DIsmissed

10/29/2013

Agency: City of Valenzuela

Protesting Entity: Frontier Power Technologies and Allied Services

Project: Supply and Installation of power generator sets for Project PRN-162-GEN SET-GOODS-2013

Dispositive Note: Resolved

09/09/2013

Agency: AFP Retirement and Separation Benefits System

Protesting Entity: M. J. Bevant Corporation

Project: Construction of Four (4) Alley Roads at Phase 1C, San Lorenzo South, Sta. Rosa Laguna

Dispositive Note: Denied

09/02/2013

Agency: Jose R. Reyes Memorial Medical Center

Protesting Entity: RB Alcazar Construction and Development

Project: Repair/Renovation of Ob-Gyne, NICU, including Hallways and repair and renovation of EENT Ward (Conversion to PhilHealth Room)

Dispositive Note: Dismissed

08/22/2013

Agency: National Irrigation Administration

Protesting Entity: Opell Construction and Development

Project: Construction of Bago RIS Canal Structures and Terminal Facilities with Contract Reference No. NIAR6-RREIS13-BAGO-CW38-13

Dispositive Note: Dismissed

07/04/2013

Agency: Department of Education - Region III Central Luzon, Division of Nueva Ecija

Protesting Entity: Far East Eagle Construction and Development (FEECAD)

Project: Project R3-D6-24-02, Sto. Rosario National High School; Project R3-D6-24-01, Jaen National High School and Project R3-D6-24-03, Talavera National High School

Dispositive Note: Dismissed

05/15/2013

Agency: Philippine Coast Guard (PCG)

Protesting Entity: Fabmik Construction and Equipment Co., Inc.

Project: Procurement of Fifteen (15) Units of M35 Truck

Dispositive Note: Denied

02/20/2013

Agency: Office of the President of the Philippines

Protesting Entity: Lockheed Detective and Watchman Agency Inc.

Project: Procurement of Private Security Services of the Office of the President CY 2013

Dispositive Note: Dismissed

12/27/2012

Agency: Department of Education (DepEd) Regional Office VIII

Protesting Entity: Villa Veronica Construction (VVC)

Project: Repair and repainting of various Buildings in Regional Office VIII

Dispositive Note: Denied

12/20/2012

Agency: House of Representatives

Protesting Entity: Lockheed Detective and Watchman Agency Inc.

Project: Annual Procurement of Private Security Agency Services for CY2013

Dispositive Note: Granted

11/26/2012

Agency: Armed Forces of the Philippines, Office of the Acting Commanding General

Protesting Entity: 911 Alarm, Inc.

Project: Procurement of Water Rescue Equipment

Dispositive Note: Denied

11/26/2012

Agency: Armed Forces of the Philippines

Protesting Entity: 911 Alarm, Inc.

Project: PB-PAFBAC-112-12, Procurement of Water Rescue Equipment

Dispositive Note: Denied

11/23/2012

Agency: University of the Philippines - Mindanao

Protesting Entity: Mati Investigation Security Agency Services, Inc.

Project: Supply of Security Services

Dispositive Note: Denied

11/20/2012

Agency: Province of Iloilo - Office of the Governor

Protesting Entity: Diomar Trading

Project: BID NO. DVP-12-0182-B

Dispositive Note: Granted

10/31/2012

Agency: Department of Health (DOH)

Protesting Entity: Macare Medical, Inc.

Project: Protest on the COBAC decision dated October 31, 2012 in the matter of the procurement of blood bank and laboratory equipment under IB NO. 2012-126

Dispositive Note: Denied

10/18/2012

Agency: Municipality of Leon, Province of Iloilo

Protesting Entity: Tacolod Enterprises, Inc

Project: Construction of Multi-purpose Public Market Building

Dispositive Note: Granted

08/15/2012

Agency: Land Bank of the Philippines

Protesting Entity: Banner Plasticard, Inc.

Project: Supply and Delivery of 555,000 pcs. ATM Plastic Card (Cash Card)

Dispositive Note: Denied

08/13/2012

Agency: Department of Health - Center for HealthDevelopment, Central Visayas

Protesting Entity: ANA Construction

Project: Upgrading of PNP Hospital (Phase II) at Gorodo Avenue, Cebu City

Dispositive Note: Denied

07/25/2012

Agency: Department of Education Region V

Protesting Entity: CPR Construction and Supply

Project: Cluster 13-Construction of School Buildings (BEFF CY 2011)

Dispositive Note: Dismissed

07/17/2012

Agency: Department of Public Works and Highways - Cordillera Administrative Region, Baguio City

Protesting Entity: MARCONS BUILDER

Project: Completion/Continuation of fence at Burnham Park, Baguio City, Project I.D. 12PD0029

Dispositive Note: Denied

07/12/2012

Agency: Division of City Schools - Tabaco City

Protesting Entity: Jag-Vail Construction & Supply

Project: Two Classroom 7m x 9m(PAGCOR Project CY 2012)

Dispositive Note: Granted

06/25/2012

Agency: National Food Authority - National Office I, San Juan La Union

Protesting Entity: Jodaar Cottage Industries

Project: Bidding for the Procurement of Rice Empty Sack (MTS)

Dispositive Note: Dismissed

06/22/2012

Agency: National Food Authority

Protesting Entity: Tiger Investigation Detective Security Agency and General Services

Project: Bidding for the NFA-Region IX Security Services

Dispositive Note: Granted

06/22/2012

Agency: Asingan Water District

Protesting Entity: VINHAR Construction & Marketing

Project: Expansion of Water Supply System in the Northern Barangays of the Municipality of Asingan.

Dispositive Note: Denied

06/13/2012

Agency: Asingan Water District

Protesting Entity: TGV Builders, Inc.

Project: Expansion of Water Supply System in the Northern Barangays of the Municipality of Asingan.

Dispositive Note: Denied

06/11/2012

Agency: Philippine Health Insurance Corporation

Protesting Entity: Mati Investigation Security Agency Services, Inc.

Project: Procurement of Security Services

Dispositive Note: Dismissed

06/07/2012

Agency: Department of Health

Protesting Entity: MAX Copy Center

Project: Reproduction of CHT forms for NHTS Families, CHT logbook (loose forms) and CHT reporting forms

Dispositive Note: Denied

05/25/2012

Agency: Lung Center of the Philippines

Protesting Entity: Zenith Medical Equipment, Inc.

Project: Procurement of Laparoscopic Equipment System

Dispositive Note: Denied

04/18/2012

Agency: Philippine Health Insurance Corporation

Protesting Entity: Banner Plasticard, Inc.

Project: Procurement of 5,300,000 pieces of Enhanced PhilHealth Identification Cards for the National Household Targeting System for Poverty Reduction (NHTS-PR)

Dispositive Note: Denied

04/10/2012

Agency: Department of Health

Protesting Entity: Sel-J Pharmaceuticals and Distributors

Project: Procurement of various Drugs and Medicines for the DOH complete treatment pack for the conditional cash transfer areas under IB no. 2012-02-06(04)

Dispositive Note: Dismissed

03/30/2012

Agency: Intramuros Administration

Protesting Entity: Ultimate Care Janitorial and Allied Services

Project: Bidding for Janitorial Services for Fiscal Year 2012

Dispositive Note: Denied

03/06/2012

Agency: DOH - Center for Health Development - Eastern Visayas

Protesting Entity: Joint Venture of AP & Printshoppe & Publishing and Malones Printing Press & Publishing House

Project: Public Bidding for the Construction of the Zumarraga level Hospital

Dispositive Note: Dismissed

02/28/2012

Agency: Province of Aklan, Office of the Provincial Governor

Protesting Entity: Diomar Trading

Project: Procurement of Medical Supplies for Ibajay District Hospital (Solicitation/ITB No. Aklan-2013-010)

Dispositive Note: Denied

02/14/2012

Agency: Government Service Insurance System

Protesting Entity: Malayan Insurance Company, Inc.

Project: City Government of Makati & Subic Bay Metropolitan Authority-International Container Terminal Services, Inc. Reinsurance Procurement

Dispositive Note: Denied

02/14/2012

Agency: Government Service Insurance System

Protesting Entity: Malayan Insurance Company, Inc.

Project: City Government of Makati & Subic Bay Metropolitan Authority-International Container Terminal Services, Inc. Reinsurance Procurement

Dispositive Note: Denied

01/18/2012

Agency: Clark Development Corporation

Protesting Entity: Kart Plaza Manufacturing, Inc.

Project: Supply and Delivery of Thirty (30) Units Brand New 2-Seater Electric Golf Carts for CDC-SPRO

Dispositive Note: Denied

01/05/2012

Agency: North Luzon Railways Corporation

Protesting Entity: ABE General Contractor

Project: Repair and Renovation of NORTHRAIL Office

Dispositive Note: Denied

12/23/2011

Agency: Home Development Mutual Fund

Protesting Entity: Logic Solutions Inc.

Project: Supply, Delivery and Installation of HDMF IP Telephony/PABX System

Dispositive Note: Denied

12/22/2011

Agency: Municipality of Kalilangan, Province of Bukidnon

Protesting Entity: OC Pizarro Construction and Supplies

Project: Construction of new Municipal Sangguniang Bayan Building of the Municipality of Kalilangan

Dispositive Note: Denied

12/08/2011

Agency: Bureau of Fire Protection Regional Headquarters - Calabarzon

Protesting Entity: Den Tronix International Trading

Project: BFP R4A, Fire Hoses 1 1/2 X 50 and 2 x 50

Dispositive Note: Denied

12/06/2011

Agency: Municipal Government of Baggao, Cagayan

Protesting Entity: Mariver Trading and General Merchanise

Project: Supply and Delivery of Biological Mosquito Larvicides

Dispositive Note: Denied

09/29/2011

Agency: Department of Health - Corazon Locsin Montelibano Memorial Regional Hospital

Protesting Entity: MedicoTek, Inc.

Project: Drop Light (LED) Operating Light

Dispositive Note: Granted

09/05/2011

Agency: Department of Social Welfare and Development - Region 10

Protesting Entity: Studio Graphics Corpoartion

Project: Printing and Delivery of "Pantawid Pamilya Guide Booklet"

Dispositive Note: Denied

08/11/2011

Agency: DTM Prints and Labels, Inc.

Protesting Entity: Power Plates Development Concepts

Project: Procurement of the Iloilo City Business Tax Plates

Dispositive Note: Denied

08/04/2011

Agency: Zamboanga City Water District

Protesting Entity: Keylargo Industrial Sales, Inc.

Project: Supply of 8,200 units of water meters

Dispositive Note: Denied

08/03/2011

Agency: Zamboanga City Water District

Protesting Entity: Zebra Construction & Development Corporation

Project: Concreting of Road and Construction of Lined Canal at Sola Street, Barangay III, Kabankalan City, Negros Occidental

Dispositive Note: Denied

07/22/2011

Agency: Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas

Protesting Entity: Ameresco Commercial and Industrial Co., Inc.

Project: Replacement of eleven (11) units PVC fill of "Marley" Cooling Tower

Dispositive Note: Denied

06/03/2011

Agency: Department of Public Works and Highways - 2nd DEO

Protesting Entity: B.C. Cuerpo Construction Corporation

Project: Rehabilitation/Improvement of Road at Patiis-Abuab Road at Brgy. Malanday Guitnang Bayan II, San Mateo Rizal

Dispositive Note: Denied

04/26/2011

Agency: DepEd-Division of Taguig City and Pateros

Protesting Entity: Trojan Marketing, Inc.

Project: Procurement of school furniture

Dispositive Note: Denied

03/10/2011

Agency: National Commission for Culture and the Arts

Protesting Entity: J.D. Legaspi Construction

Project: NA

Dispositive Note: Denied for filing out of time

03/07/2011

Agency: National Irrigation Administration

Protesting Entity: Brostan Construction and Development

Project: Construction of Bulao Diversion Dam, Irrigation and Drainage Canals and Appurtenant Facilities/ Structures Including Supply, Delivery and Installation of Steel Gates for HCAAP.

Dispositive Note: Granted

02/17/2011

Agency: Department of Public Works and Highways - Office of the District Engineer - Zamboanga City

Protesting Entity: Unitec Builders, Inc.

Project: Repair/Rehabilitation of Barangay Road, Bunguiao, Zamboanga City

Dispositive Note: Denied

01/17/2011

Agency: Department of Public Works and Highways

Protesting Entity: J.D. Legaspi Construction

Project: Improvement of Sito Libis-Bulihan Centro Roxas-Duluhan Road, Bulihan Arc, San Antonio, Quezon Province

Dispositive Note: Denied Motion for Reconsideration

01/12/2011

Agency: Land Transportation Office - Regional Office 2

Protesting Entity: Region Security and Investigation Agency

Project: Delivery of Security Services

Dispositive Note: Denied due to lack of basis

01/03/2011

Agency: Corazon Locsin Montelibano Memorial Regional Hospital

Protesting Entity: Phi Pharmawealth Incorporated

Project: Sevoflurane for Drugs and Medi

Dispositive Note: Granted Protest

01/03/2011

Agency: Environmental Management Bureau - Department of Environment and Natural Resources

Protesting Entity: BP Integrated Technologies, Inc.

Project: NA

Dispositive Note: Denied Motion for Reconsideration

12/28/2010

Agency: National Bureau of Investigation

Protesting Entity: System & Plan Integrator & Development Corporation

Project: NBI Citizen's Database and Information System Project

Dispositive Note: Denied Motion for Reconsideration

12/22/2010

Agency: St. Anthony Mother and Child Hospital

Protesting Entity: San Narciso Builders Corporation

Project: Construction of a 3 storey Annex Building, Completion of the 3rd floor of Dr. Manuel Cuenco Building and Ramp

Dispositive Note: Denied for non-compliance

12/17/2010

Agency: Philippine Reclamation Authority

Protesting Entity: J.D. Legaspi Corporation

Project: Construction of the Service Road at Superblock A

Dispositive Note: Denied for lack of merit

12/16/2010

Agency: National Youth Commission

Protesting Entity: Care Best International, Inc.

Project: Procurement of Janitorial Services

Dispositive Note: Denied Motion for Reconsideration

12/10/2010

Agency: Veterans Memorial Medical Center

Protesting Entity: Jagas Dental Trading

Project: Procurement of four (4) units Dental Chair

Dispositive Note: Denied for lack of merit

09/27/2010

Agency: Zamboanga City Water District

Protesting Entity: Keylargo Industrial Sales

Project: Supply and delivery of 3,000 Units of Water Meters 1/2 Class C Positive Displacement Type, Volumetric, Plastic Casing

Dispositive Note: Denied for lack of merit

09/09/2010

Agency: Province of Daval del Norte

Protesting Entity: Davao Rock Mixer Enterprises

Project: Improvement of Balet-Danao-Kila Road

Dispositive Note: Dismissed for lack of merit

08/20/2010

Agency: Philippine Nuclear Research Institute

Protesting Entity: Simplified Builders

Project: Construction of two (2) storey building extension of Cobalt 60 irradiation facility building (Phase 2) and upgrading of the existing radioactive waste facility

Dispositive Note: Denied for non-compliance

08/05/2010

Agency: Social Security System

Protesting Entity: Greenmar Phils.

Project: Supply, delivery and installation of tellering booth, bill/money counter and cash safe/vault for various SSS Branch Offices.

Dispositive Note: Denied for non-compliance in the submission of the

06/07/2010

Agency: Veterans Memorial Medical Center

Protesting Entity: Ultimate Care Janitorial Services

Project: Janitorial Services

Dispositive Note: Denied for violation of the contract agreement

05/21/2010

Agency: North Luzon Railways Corporation

Protesting Entity: Superb Security & Investigation Agency, Inc.

Project: Security Services

Dispositive Note: Dismissed for lack of merit

04/12/2010

Agency: Philippine International Trading Corporation

Protesting Entity: Super Trade Enterprises

Project: Supply and Delivery of Brand New Mototr Vehicles and Motorcycles for the PDEA

Dispositive Note: Dismissed for lack of merit

03/18/2010

Agency: Southern Philippines Medical Center

Protesting Entity: Mati Investigation and Allied Services, Inc.

Project: Security Services

Dispositive Note: Denied being filed out of time

02/18/2010

Agency: DepEd NCR

Protesting Entity: LGR Athletic Wears, Inc.

Project: Supply and Delivery of Sports Athletic Uniforms for the Palarong Pambansaa CY 2010

Dispositive Note: Denied for filing out of time

01/29/2010

Agency: Davao Medical Center

Protesting Entity: Redmark Industrial and Medical Supplies

Project: Lease of Chemistry and Immunology equipments and its reagents and laboratory supplies

Dispositive Note: Denied for failure to meet or comply with the tech

01/22/2010

Agency: Municipality of Sinait, Province of Ilocos Sur

Protesting Entity: Magscon Construction

Project: Various Infrastructure projects

Dispositive Note: Denied for repeating the same issues that was alre

12/11/2009

Agency: Philippine Science High School

Protesting Entity: San Narciso Builders

Project: Construction of Academic HUB

Dispositive Note: Granted. Decision of the bids and awards committee

12/03/2009

Agency: DOH-Amang Rodriguez Memorial Medical Center

Protesting Entity: Ritegroup Marketing, Inc

Project: Procurement of Blood Bags

Dispositive Note: Denied for lack of merit

08/07/2009

Agency: National Printing Office

Protesting Entity: Ready Form Inc.

Project: Printing of Government Accountable Forms

Dispositive Note: Appeal from the decision of NPO is Denied

04/20/2009

Agency: Department of Health

Protesting Entity: Phil. Pharmawealth, Inc.

Project: Procurement of Anti-TB Drugs for Children

Dispositive Note: Denied for failure to meet or comply with the elig

02/12/2009

Agency: Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas

Protesting Entity: Safeco Environmental Services, Inc.

Project: Removal of the Structural Fireproofing Materials on Steel Beams of the Multi-storey Building

Dispositive Note: Reconsidered under the minimum eligibility require